New Research on Smoking Versus Vaping

Last week new research comparing smoking versus vaping hit the public. Here’s what two of the studies mean for vapers.

One study compared emissions from smoking and vaping alongside the ways that people use both types of tobacco delivery methods. The idea was to see whether there are differences in toxins in emissions, and whether use patterns affect how users perceive any differences.

The second study examined the size of particles that users inhale during vaping, and the locations of where those particles get deposited in the body during vaping.

Smoking versus vaping actual use study

A team of scientists at British American Tobacco (BAT) began this work based on a theory: the way people use vaping products and tobacco heating products (THPs) can affect how much toxins they inhale. This new study with Italian consumers shows their analysis of how the actual use of vape products and THPs compares with smoking in terms of toxins.

The team found that vapor and THP emissions contained far fewer of the listed toxicants at lower levels than did cigarette smoke. However, the team also investigated the actual way consumers used these products, comparing use patterns for the THP glo, another commercially available THP, the vaping product iSwitch, and a reference traditional cigarette.

The scientists considered puffing topography, which included puffing duration, frequency, and volume, and corresponding mouth level exposure (MLE) to vapor. This is in addition to average daily consumption of the products, a standard reference point in these types of studies.

The team found overall consumption was less for THPs than for cigarettes, with MLE to dry particulate matter significantly lower. This was true even though on average the consumers took puffs of similar duration and volume on both the cigarette and vapor product. The difference could be important for smokers.

“As an example, glo THP emissions contain around 90 percent less of certain toxicants than a cigarette* — a reduction that is amplified by the reduced average daily consumption by consumers,” Joshua Jones, BAT Human Studies Scientist, said in a press release. “This data adds to growing evidence that Italian consumers are exposed to much lower levels of certain toxicants when using THPs and vapor products compared with traditional cigarettes, suggesting these products have the potential to be reduced risk compared with smoking.”

*Comparison of smoke from a scientific standard reference cigarette (approx. 9 mg tar) and vapor from iSwitch, or aerosol from heated tobacco in glo (as applicable), in terms of the 9 harmful components the World Health Organization recommends to reduce in cigarette smoke. This quality does not necessarily mean this product is less harmful than (other) tobacco products.

Vaping particle size study

Researchers have begun to analyze how vaping practices and other factors such as device power and e-liquid composition affect the size of e-cigarettes and where in the body they are deposited. Obviously, this is part of the smoking versus vaping question.

[This study should be considered a preliminary look for a few reasons, such as the small initial sample size, the uncertainty of using the smoking machine, and the fact that the researchers were estimating for some of the findings.]

Typically, e-liquids contain flavoring agents, nicotine, and a base material, such as propylene glycol (PG) or vegetable glycerin. These are safe to eat, but the jury is still out on their longterm impact on the lungs, especially since their effects might be different when inhaled at high temperatures.

The team observed 23 volunteers engage in vaping sessions. They then compared these findings to simulate results from a smoking machine. [This is not a publicly available study, so I could not get any more information about how they did this, but they apparently were using it to produce vapor, not smoke.]

The scientists then collected the vapor. They identified particles in the vapor and measured their size and distribution. They that vegetable glycerin-based e-liquids and higher device power settings produced larger particles. Additionally, slower air flow—or longer puffs where the volume remains the same—generated significantly larger particles.

The team “estimated” where most of the particles were deposited, and again, I cannot see the full study for an explanation of why this was necessary. In any event, they found that there were fewer e-cigarette particles and that those were smaller than those generated by regular smoking, but that all the particles had similar deposition patterns in the human airway.

In other words: neither study found no risk from vaping e-cigarettes, but both imply less risk than smoking.

Related Posts

An image depicting a bladder cancer tumor

Vapers May Be at Higher Risk for Bladder Cancer

A new bladder cancer study reveals that vapers may be at elevated risk compared to non-smokers and never vapers. Specifically, vaping and bladder cancer may be linked, although smokers too are already known to be at risk. Scientists conducting a recent meta-analysis of multiple research studies identified six substances strongly linked to bladder cancer in

Read More »
a woman looks afraid, holding her face, maybe as she experiences temporary psychiatric symptoms like paranoia

Cannabis Linked With Temporary Psychiatric Symptoms

Millions use cannabis worldwide, both recreationally and medically. New research, however, links temporary psychiatric symptoms and cannabis use, even for first time users. This suggests we should see the benefits and risks of cannabis use as a nuanced debate—one that depends in part on the active compounds in the particular cannabis used. Temporary Psychiatric Symptoms A

Read More »
JUUL vape with nicotine vape pods

Young Adults Don’t Always Know What’s In Their Vape Pods

According to new research from a Stanford University team, young adults often don’t know what’s in their nicotine vape pods, including what brand they use. Pod-based e-cigarettes look a lot like thumb drives, but they are vaping devices. They consist of a vaporizer base powered by a rechargeable battery, and vape pods that you snap

Read More »
Scroll to Top